London image

London

Founded in 2012, Signature Litigation has grown into one of London’s pre-eminent specialist dispute resolution practices. From the outset, we set out to do things differently: a conflict-free, disputes-only platform designed to give clients the undivided focus and strategic agility that complex, high-stakes matters demand.

FIND OUT MORE
Gibraltar image

Gibraltar

Established in 2017, Signature Litigation's Gibraltar office was founded to address growing demand for specialist expertise in commercial litigation and private wealth disputes on the Rock.

FIND OUT MORE
Paris image

Paris

Signature Litigation AARPI houses one of France’s most enviable product liability practices, with the team also handling commercial and corporate litigation, insurance and reinsurance, toxic tort and ESG, civil fraud and asset tracing, international arbitration, administrative and public law.

FIND OUT MORE
Frankfurt image

Frankfurt

Frankfurt has emerged as one of Europe's foremost financial and commercial centres and, increasingly, as a bridge between European and Asian markets. With that growth comes an increasing demand for sophisticated dispute resolution. Signature Litigation established its Frankfurt office to meet this need, bringing our conflict-free, disputes-only platform to the German market.

FIND OUT MORE

Signature Litigation clients obtain permission to serve claims on sitting Head of State

28 May 2021

The context: The Republic of Mozambique has brought claims before the English Courts challenging state guarantees of the financing for certain projects related to the protection and development of Mozambique's territorial waters.  Signature Litigation's clients (including certain Privinvest companies) are among the defendants to those claims, which they dispute.  Credit Suisse entities are also defendants to the claim and have brought additional claims against our clients, which are also disputed.  If, however, any of the Republic and/or Credit Suisse's claims succeed, our clients maintain that other parties are also liable for those claims, including the current President of Mozambique, the former President and the former Minister of Finance.

The application and ruling:  Our clients issued their additional claims in January 2021, but required the Court's permission to serve those claims on parties out of the jurisdiction, including the President of Mozambique, Filipe Nyusi.  The application was heard on 21 May 2021, at the end of which Mrs Justice Cockerill granted permission to serve the claims out of the jurisdiction on all of the relevant parties, including President Nyusi.

The Court and the parties were alive to the potential seriousness of serving a sitting foreign Head of State to answer these claims.  However, Cockerill J was ultimately "amply satisfied that the merits hurdle is met in relation to both the third party and [President Nyusi]."  Cockerill J also noted that she had given "careful and anxious consideration to the question of sovereign immunity" but was satisfied that our clients' case as to why President Nyusi is not entitled to assert immunity in relation to the claims "is well over the arguability hurdle."   In summary, our clients maintain that President Nyusi (who was not President at the relevant time) is not entitled to assert immunity as the relevant conduct (including representations in relation to donations to his presidential election campaign) occurred in the course of professional activity outside his official functions.

Tom Snelling, Partner at Signature Litigation, commented: "We are delighted to have successfully represented our clients at this important hearing, working closely with a fantastic Counsel team led by Duncan Matthews QC."

The proceedings continue, and steps will now be taken to effect the service on the defendants to our clients' claims.  This latest decision follows our clients' recent victory in the Court of Appeal, which in March 2021 held that the Republic's claims brought against the Privinvest companies in the High Court all fall within relevant arbitration agreements (see here).

Signature's clients were represented by Duncan Matthews QC, Professor Philippa Webb (both of Twenty Essex) and Ben Woolgar (Brick Court Chambers), instructed by Signature Litigation (the team includes Graham Huntley, Tom Snelling, Tadhg O'Leary, Adriano Stagni and Elif Acar.)